đ Key insights
Democracy Is a Hammer, Not a Sacred Object â Jason Brennan treats forms of government as tools, to be judged by how well they work. I discuss with him why people defend democracy as an expression of equality, and why that defence is shaky. If equality were all that mattered, we would pick leaders by lottery, which is far more egalitarian than any election. Almost nobody wants that, which shows we care about outcomes and not only about fairness.
Most Voting Is Team Loyalty, Not Policy Choice â The âMichigan modelâ of democratic realism says people donât vote for what they want, they vote for who they are. Brennan compares voters to sports fans: they pick a team for social reasons, then adopt its views. When a party flips its platform, most of its voters follow without noticing, and when asked, they insist they always believed it.
Ignorance Is Rational, Not Stupid â A single vote is a crumb of power, so learning about politics costs more than it returns. Brennan likens it to a class where everyone gets the average grade: nobody studies, and the class fails. His proposed fixes include enlightened preference voting, which simulates what an informed public would choose, and randomly selected citizen assemblies.
đ Go deeper
đĽ Related videos:
Bryan Caplan: The Myth of the Rational Voter (Brno, 2022) â Caplan explains ârational irrationalityâ: when your vote costs you nothing, it is cheap to hold comfortable, biased beliefs.
Ethics in AI Live Event: Open Democracy in the Age of AI (HĂŠlène Landemore, Oxford) â The other side of the debate: power spread to ordinary citizens through lotteries and citizensâ assemblies.
đ Further reading:
Democracy for Realists â Christopher Achen & Larry Bartels: The most rigorous case that voters follow group identity, not policy. It is the evidence base behind the sports-team analogy.
Open Democracy â HĂŠlène Landemore: A serious answer to Brennan: instead of limiting who decides, put randomly selected citizens at the centre of the system.
đĄ Think for Yourself
If your party swapped its platform with its rivalâs tomorrow, would you notice? Would you leave?
If your vote has almost no chance of changing the outcome, what are you actually doing when you vote?
âď¸ Thought Experiment
Next election, your country picks 500 citizens by lottery and pays them to study the issues for a year. They alone make the decision. Their choice is fairer than any vote, and may be wiser. Would you accept it? And if you refuse, is it because you care about fairness, or because you want your side to win?
Cheers,
Kevin

